Comments on "oak"

[Hide] original entry

My choir had a rehearsal today at the chapel at Churchill College. I was pleased to find that there were trees nearby, so that I was able to lean my bike up against some oak.

The story of the founding of the chapel is interesting. Some of the fellows of Churchill were passionately opposed to there being a chapel at the college, and so the chapel is not in fact the chapel of Churchill College; it is owned and operated by a separate trust, and merely happens to be located on Churchill's premises.

This wasn't enough for Francis Crick, who resigned his fellowship in protest at the building of the chapel. He had an exchange of letters with Winston Churchill along the following lines:

Crick: I am resigning my fellowship in protest at the institution of a chapel at Churchill College.

Churchill: I'm sorry to hear that. I don't really understand the problem. The chapel will be an amenity for the benefit of those students who want to use it, and no one else will ever have to set foot in it.

Crick: Very well. I enclose a cheque for ten guineas towards the founding of the Churchill Brothel. I am sure you will agree that there can be no reasonable objection to this; it will be an amenity for the benefit of those students who want to use it, and no one else will ever have to set foot in it.

(Actually Crick, being an erudite chap, called it the College Hetairae. The "cheque for ten guineas" was a reference to the fact that when the colleged had decided some time before that it would not spend any of its own money on a chapel, some eminent chap -- I forget who -- had immediately sent them a cheque for the same sum towards a chapel-building fund.)

On 2007-10-21 at 01:56:24, Robert Hulme said:

What happened after Crick sent that message?

On 2007-10-21 at 02:21:52, g said:

I don't think history records, but apparently there's a note scribbled on Crick's letter (in some archive of Churchill's papers, I suppose) saying something like "Cheque returned with compliments", which suggests that Churchill decided Crick was just playing silly buggers and dropped the subject.

On 2007-10-21 at 09:36:38, Robert Hulme said:

There go my plans for the weekend then.

On 2007-10-21 at 10:14:17, Aldabra said:

Didn't Crick then move to King's? Which diminishes his moral point rather. Speaking of which, this comment window is advertising Ann Coulter's weekly column and Newt Gingrich's newsletter, which is presumably not your intention.

On 2007-10-21 at 10:46:20, g said:

I haven't been able to find any sign that Crick moved to King's.

I didn't even know there *were* advertisements. (My web browser blocks them, and I evidently didn't read all the small print.) Ugh, I hate hate hate HaloScan. Definitely time to look at other commenting systems, or implement my own, or move to LY or WordPress or TypePad or something.

On 2007-10-21 at 11:16:55, Robert Hulme said:

By LY do you mean LJ?

On 2007-10-21 at 11:29:24, g said:

Er, yes. Not my day today, is it?

On 2007-10-21 at 12:02:14, Ashley Yakeley said:

My sister got married in that chapel (to the then vice-master of Churchill) in 2004.

On 2007-10-21 at 13:48:30, g said:

Cool! I rather like the building, at least from the inside. Very fine stained glass, and the Dali-ish cross works well with the brutalist square concrete structure. (Though I'm not so very keen on the brutalist concrete itself.)

Post a comment:

Name:(will be shown with comment)
Email:(will be kept private)
Web page:(optional; will be linked from your name)
Secret word:(the secret word is two plus two)

You may use Markdown to format your comment, or just include HTML tags. All comments are moderated, so don't waste your time trying to abuse this.